Problems

[Eowyn, Lady of Rohan]

What are some of the mistakes Peter Jackson made?

1. puting Arwen at the ford.
2. Making Elrond to mean

[Elvengirl]

A few things I didn't like:

Faramir
The Ring at Osgiliath
Saruman's hold over King Theoden
Aragorn falling off the cliff

[Insidious Rex]

Originally posted by Elvengirl
A few things I didn't like:

Faramir
The Ring at Osgiliath

oh dont get me started....

Saruman's hold over King Theoden
Aragorn falling off the cliff

Well since all the others actualy have threads of their own Ill jump on the Theoden thing. Why did you have such a problem with it? I thought it worked pretty well.

[Lizra]

Yes I liked theTheoden King changes also, they worked well for the movie.

I thought the orcs were made into "comic book style" hideous monster villians. Too much of a "bad" thing! Because the evil guys were "super steroided", the good guys had to go overboard too!. It took away from the character development and the intellectual battle of good and evil (for me!)

[Gwaimir Windgem]

Sticking Arwen in the movie at all. :rolleyes:

[azalea]

I'm going to go ahead and close this thread, because we have opinion threads for both Fellowship and TTT, as well as the threads on specific parts of the movies, as Lizra mentioned (like the threads about Arwen, and the Elrond thread). Please do post there about things you didn't like.