one ring musical

[The Lady of the Wood]

since when is there going to be a musical??anyway, i doubt it will be as good as the movie :rolleyes:

[hama1]

I doubt it will be as good as the movie as well. I also doubt that elves are going to show up at helm's deep. I doubt that Faramir will try to take the Ring. I doubt that Theoden will look like he got put in a freezer for a few months. I doubt Frodo and Sam will end up in Osgiliath (sp?) I doubt as I am adapting the novel to the stage I will have the hubris to assume I can tell the story better than Tolkien did. I doubt that Eomir will be banished instead of being imprisoned. I doubt that everytime Frodo risks putting on the Ring that I will suggest that the actor protraying him roll his eyes back into his head and pretend to be on a bad acid trip. I doubt I will leave out as much good and powerful dialogue as Peter Jackson did. Yes. Clearly I have my doubts....

[Wayfarer]

At least you can avoid making blatently stupid mistakes, hama.

[hama1]

Wayfarer,

I doubt I have made baltantly stupid mistakes. I am certain they are mistakes of another kind altogether.

[Wayfarer]

You're ok then. :D

[Agburanar]

I think as long as you're only cutting some bits you'll be okay. But please don't start adding bits like some stupid director I could name...
(mumble, mumble, if they were meant to bethere Tolkien would have put them there, mumble, mumble...):mad:

[hama1]

add bits...? we are talking three hours...there is no time to add bits.... And I don't have Liv Tyler to insert in the show...thank god....Now Gwyn Paltrow as Eowyn I can see....Hmmmmm...:D

[Guardian_of_the_Forest]

I would like to see how it turns out.

[Beleg Strongbow]

I doubt that Arwen will get the chance to show off her bipolar personality:
MANIC: "If you want him, then come and claim him!"
DEPRESSIVE: Well, okay. Even if he does become King, I guess I'll still abandon him.:D

I think that doubts about the musical should be offset by the parts that you do get right, hama.

[hama1]

Beleg,

I would be fascinated and very appreciative if you would tell me which parts you think I have gotten wrong. I am always looking to improve what I have done so far.

Hama