lorien VS Fangorn

[donut dunker]

which forest do you like the best? Mirkwood don't count because it harbours evil and Fangorn was redeemed by the Ents... so what is it guys?????
Mine has to be lorien(sp?) because its the elf wood, and a place of magic

[Xivigg]

I have to say that i like Fangorn better than lorien

the ent are soooo cool :)

[Morkhon]

Lorien, the Lady Galadriel gives it the edge.

[Syntia]

Indeed you're right

Galadriel is like a sister for me :)

[Xivigg]

Look at this young one

another one who got delusion of grandeur

[Fat middle]

bored, Xivigg? :p

[Xivigg]

What can make you say that ??

Hey i'm blasting myself
it's perfectly normal

don't you think ??

[anduin]

Of course, of course. *backs away slowly* ;)

[RovingTurtle]

*Another Canadian Spammer Spotted*
*Roger That*
;)

Fangorn, hummmmmmm mustn't be hasty

[arynetrek]

Doriath.

because -

Fangorn is a little "alien" - Tolkien gives it that feelign on purpose, not just with the "don't go into Fangorn" warnings that the Company recieves, but with the atmosphere of it - Fangorn reminds me a LOT of Bombadil's forest (which is something else i think Tolkien intentionally did) & makes it a place that CAN be welcoming but is more often unnerving.

Lorien, by the time we see it, is beautiful; but it's almost a relic. the Elves are quickly fading, & most of them are not long to remain in ME. that feeling just permeates Lorien, & makes it a very sad place underneath the Elven wonders that live there.

Doriath is THE enchanted Elven-wood.

(oh god, more voting for third parties...)

aryne *

[Fat middle]

i'm with aryn. Doriath is best.

[Xivigg]

Ok then if i can add a choice i'll vote for mirkwood

lot's of spider in it and elve and Dol Guldur

everything one an want :lol:

[Elanor]

I like Fangorn and Lorien equally well; aren't they always warning travelers not to risk getting entangled in each other? Well, they each have their good points, and they're both very insular (what's with forests being insular?). I like the Old Forest too, because it has Bombadil in it. And didn't I say my favorite place in middle earth was inside the Old Willow? That willow is my friend.

[andustar]

still deciding: Lorien with Galadriel or Doriath with Melian...

i think i vote Doriath :)