The Three top most debated Tolkien book topics!

[Finrod Felagund]

I'd have to say

1. Balrog Wings
2. Who IS Tom Bombadil
3. Glorfindel & Glorfindel

PLUS

4. Elf Ears: Pointy?
5. Arwen's Immortality? (Esp. thanks to RotK)

[azalea]

I'd change "Glorfindel" to "elf ears.":)

[Sister Golden Hair]

Another one I have seen on various MBs is: "Is gollum really a Hobbit?"

This thread probably is more suited to the Middle-earth forum. Moving.

[Falagar]

Arwen's "immortality" (and Half-elves in general) would be my number three on the list.

[Bombadillo]

Also "Who/What is Sauron?" Heh, basicly anything that asks for an exact explaination of a character.

I liked the Balrogs Don't Have Wings topic. :p I tried to revive that about a month ago, but it's vanished from the board.

[Radagast The Brown]

Originally posted by Bombadillo
Also "Who/What is Sauron?" Heh, basicly anything that asks for an exact explaination of a character.

I liked the Balrogs Don't Have Wings topic. :p I tried to revive that about a month ago, but it's vanished from the board. It's not really a debate, I think, about who/what is Sauron... it's more like a question-answer.